What is central bank digital currency (CBDC)?

In the dynamic landscape of financial transactions, the tangible sensation of cold, hard cash is becoming increasingly rare. The global shift, especially accentuated during the COVID-19 pandemic due to health concerns and the convenience of digital transactions, is steering us towards a predominantly cashless future. Digital transactions have seen an upsurge, with banks and financial institutions processing a significantly higher volume of them as compared to traditional in-branch operations.

This digital financial revolution has been accelerated by innovations like cryptocurrencies and the robust framework of blockchain technology. While thousands of cryptocurrencies have emerged, their decentralized nature stands in contrast to government-issued currencies. Notably, Bitcoin and its ilk represent decentralized digital currencies, with their authenticity anchored in distributed ledger technology (DLT). This ensures that transaction veracity is concurrently validated by numerous devices globally instead of a centralized authority.

Recognizing this trend, central banks worldwide are exploring the prospect of issuing their own digital currencies, commonly referred to as Central Bank Digital Currencies (CBDCs). Unlike cryptocurrencies, which operate in a decentralized environment, CBDCs are state-sanctioned and managed, representing a digital version of a nation's official currency. They are not tethered to physical commodities and are introduced by central entities responsible for a country's monetary policies, such as the US Federal Reserve, the Bank of Japan, the People's Bank of China (PBOC), and Germany's Deutsche Bundesbank.

While CBDCs bear some resemblance to stablecoins, a type of private cryptocurrency pegged to an asset or another currency to maintain value stability, they differ fundamentally. Stablecoins operate in the private sector, while CBDCs are sovereign, state-issued digital currencies. Their inception is viewed as a response to the surging popularity of digital currencies and is anticipated to reshape the global financial ecosystem.

As we navigate this evolving digital economy, the debate between CBDCs and traditional cryptocurrencies remains vibrant, shaping the future of monetary exchanges and financial systems.

Which varieties of CBDCs exist, and where have they been implemented?

CBDCs are not monolithic; their designs and implementation strategies vary widely across the globe. One prominent type is the account-based model, exemplified by DCash in the Eastern Caribbean. In this model, consumers have direct deposit accounts with the central bank, ensuring a straightforward connection between the bank and its users. Conversely, China's e-CNY, a significant CBDC initiative, leans on private-sector banks for the issuance and management of digital-currency accounts. This approach was notably demonstrated during the 2022 Beijing Olympic Games, where attendees, including athletes, were able to transact using e-CNY within the Olympic premises.

The European Central Bank is mulling over a different approach for its potential digital euro. In this model, certified financial institutions would each control a permissioned node on a blockchain network, acting as channels for the digital currency's distribution. There's also a concept, favored by cryptocurrency enthusiasts, wherein government-issued fiat currency, not backed by tangible commodities, would be introduced as anonymous fungible tokens, ensuring user privacy.

As of now, a staggering 87 nations, which account for over 90% of the world's GDP, are examining the prospects of CBDCs. Some notable developments include:

Jamaica's JAM-DEX, inaugurated in June 2022, stands as the premier CBDC officially recognized as legal tender. While it offers a straightforward utility, it lacks advanced functionalities like cross-border payment integration for smart contracts. It's worth noting that JAM-DEX operates without a blockchain foundation, unlike the Bahamas' Sand Dollar and the Eastern Caribbean's DCash.

Nigeria marked a milestone as the pioneering African nation to introduce a CBDC, unveiling the eNaira in October 2021.

Sub-Saharan Africa is on the cusp of a CBDC revolution. The extensive adoption of M-PESA, a renowned mobile money transfer platform, has laid a robust foundation, both socially and financially, for CBDCs' potential extensive use in the region.

Project Aber stands out as a collaborative venture between Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates' central banks. This initiative delves into the feasibility of a co-issued digital currency, aiming to facilitate both domestic and international settlements between these two nations.

Why are CBDCs on the radar of many central banks?

Several converging trends have piqued the interest of central banks in CBDCs, underscoring their potential role in the evolving financial landscape:

Decline in Cash Transactions: Over recent years, there's been a notable shift away from traditional cash transactions. Europe, for instance, witnessed a drop in cash usage by about one-third from 2014 to 2021. In countries like Norway, cash-based transactions have become a rarity, accounting for a mere 3 percent of total payments. Such a significant drift compels central banks to introspect and redefine their significance in the contemporary monetary framework.

Surge in Private Digital Assets: The allure of digital assets, especially cryptocurrencies, has grown exponentially. In the UK, data suggests that one in ten adults either currently possesses or has previously held a digital asset. Reports from the European Central Bank highlight that in six major EU nations, nearly 10 percent of households have a stake in digital assets. The burgeoning consumer engagement with these digital assets poses a potential threat to the traditional fiat currency, challenging its supremacy as the primary value measurement standard.

Central Banks' Diminished Image as Payment Pioneers: Over time, central banks have experienced a dip in their stature as frontrunners in payment innovations. CBDCs present them with a renewed chance to spearhead pivotal discussions about the relevance and application of cash in today's digital age, promoting transparency and fostering public engagement.

Emergence of Globalized Payment Systems: With the world becoming increasingly interconnected, payment systems have adopted a more globalized character. Central banks, recognizing the challenges and opportunities this presents, are keen on exerting more localized control over these expansive systems. They perceive CBDCs as a potential anchoring tool that can infuse stability into local digital payment infrastructures.

While the potential advantages of CBDCs are manifold, ranging from streamlined transactions to enhanced financial inclusion, they aren't devoid of challenges. Concerns about security, the impact on traditional banking systems, and the implications for monetary policy are just a few considerations central banks must address. As the world treads this uncharted territory, a thorough exploration of both the benefits and risks associated with CBDCs becomes imperative.

CBDC vs Cryptocurrency

Central bank digital currencies (CBDCs) are often conflated with other forms of digital assets, but there are stark differences that set them apart. Central to this distinction is the governance structure. While CBDCs are overseen and issued by central banks, cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin emerge from a decentralized network using cryptographic techniques and operate on blockchain technology.

Cryptocurrencies function on public blockchains, which are open and permissionless. This means any individual can partake in the fundamental operations of the network. The transparency of public blockchains allows anyone to read, write, and audit transactions, ensuring the self-regulating nature of these networks. In contrast, CBDCs typically operate on private blockchains. These are more like secure, closed databases rooted in cryptographic principles, and they lack the decentralization inherent in public blockchains.

While cryptocurrency networks distribute authority among its users, who make decisions through consensus mechanisms, CBDCs are tightly regulated by the central bank's rules and policies. This centralization is a defining feature of CBDCs, in contrast to the decentralized nature of cryptocurrencies. Moreover, while cryptocurrencies can offer users a degree of anonymity, CBDCs are designed to provide transparency, enabling central banks to monitor transactions and ownership.

Technologically, CBDCs might not always rely on the same blockchain platforms that underpin many cryptocurrencies. And, contrary to popular belief, CBDCs are distinct from stablecoins. While stablecoins are pegged to traditional fiat currencies (like the U.S. dollar), a CBDC isn't just pegged to its respective fiat currency – it essentially represents that currency in digital form. For instance, a digital dollar as a CBDC would have the same intrinsic value as a physical dollar bill.

The utility of CBDCs is primarily for transactions, and they aren't meant for long-term holding or speculative investments. In contrast, cryptocurrencies can be used for a myriad of purposes, including both payments and investments.

One of the potential drawbacks of CBDCs, when compared to cryptocurrencies, is the reduced emphasis on data privacy. The decentralized, peer-to-peer nature of cryptocurrencies grants users a level of autonomy in their transactions and the data they share. However, CBDCs, being centralized, could relay substantial transactional information to regulatory bodies, potentially raising concerns about user privacy and financial surveillance.

What are the potential benefits of CBDCs?

Central bank digital currencies (CBDCs) are emerging as pivotal tools in the realm of digital finance, offering solutions to longstanding challenges and reshaping the financial landscape. Their advocates highlight several profound advantages:

Cost Efficiency: By redirecting investments from physical infrastructure to digital finance, financial-service providers could potentially save up to $400 billion annually. However, the transition to CBDCs will necessitate significant capital for technological advancements and system integration.
Speed and Efficiency: CBDCs promise to enhance the speed of electronic payment systems across nations. The real-time settlement of transactions could revolutionize cross-border trade and daily commerce.
Financial Inclusion: Nearly 5% of US adults and 1.6 billion people globally lack access to traditional banking. CBDCs, especially those accessible via mobile devices, have the potential to bridge this gap. By bypassing the need for expensive banking infrastructure, especially in developing nations, CBDCs can offer a direct link between central banks and consumers. However, ensuring widespread adoption will be crucial, as many might still prefer the anonymity of cash transactions.
Enhanced Security: CBDCs can elevate payment security standards. Regulated digital currencies, combined with private-key cryptography, can ensure that transactions are both finalized and immutable, minimizing fraud risks and providing users with more confidence in their financial activities.
Government Operations and Monetary Policy: CBDCs can streamline governmental functions, from the distribution of social benefits to tax collection, by automating and digitizing processes. They can also bolster the efficacy of monetary policies, offering central banks a more direct means to implement financial strategies.
Reduced Third-Party Risks: Traditional money transactions involve intermediaries, introducing vulnerabilities like bank runs or cash shortages. CBDCs, being directly overseen by central banks, can circumvent these risks, ensuring system stability.
Privacy and Transparency: CBDCs can offer calibrated privacy features. While value-based CBDCs can provide transaction anonymity akin to physical cash, account-based CBDCs can incorporate selective transparency, balancing user privacy with regulatory oversight.
Combatting Illicit Activities: The digital nature of CBDCs, coupled with cryptographic security and public ledgers, can deter unlawful activities. Central banks can trace funds seamlessly, reducing the avenues for money laundering or other illicit financial actions.

As the world grapples with the challenges and opportunities of an increasingly digital financial ecosystem, CBDCs stand out as a promising solution. By addressing issues of efficiency, access, and security, they have the potential to redefine our understanding of money and its role in society.

Are there any potential risks or downsides to CBDCs?

As central banks globally express keen interest in the prospects of CBDCs, it's essential to understand the multifaceted challenges and considerations that accompany this innovation.

One of the primary concerns is the traceability of digital money. With every transaction being digital and traceable, taxation becomes more straightforward. However, this enhanced transparency, as predicted by analysts, may pose a barrier to voluntary adoption. Citizens might be wary of the potential loss of financial privacy.

Technological stability is another significant concern. The digital version of the Eastern Caribbean DCash, for instance, faced a two-month offline period in January 2022 due to technical glitches. Such disruptions highlight the teething problems of transitioning to a digital financial infrastructure.

Moreover, the business justification for CBDCs is under scrutiny. The resources and effort required by central banks to build a robust digital currency infrastructure might outweigh the benefits, especially when many developed nations are already achieving instant payments using existing infrastructure. Some countries, like Canada and Singapore, have even concluded that the current landscape doesn't present a compelling case for adopting digital currencies.

Despite the promise of CBDCs to revolutionize transactions, centralization remains a significant issue. The power to oversee and authorize transactions still resides with a central entity—the central bank. This centralization means that every financial activity becomes visible to the overseeing authority, raising privacy concerns. Such a scenario draws parallels with the data privacy challenges faced by major tech companies and ISPs. The potential for malicious actors to exploit this data or for central banks to limit peer-to-peer transactions adds to these concerns.

Cross-border payments, although poised to benefit from CBDCs, face hurdles of their own. While CBDCs can facilitate real-time cross-border and cross-currency transactions, diverse legal and regulatory environments across nations pose challenges. Harmonizing these disparate frameworks is no small feat.

Lastly, the geopolitical implications of CBDCs cannot be ignored. The introduction of digital currencies by major economies, such as China's digital yuan, could potentially challenge the dominance of currencies like the U.S. dollar in global trade. Should global corporations adopt the digital yuan for trade with China, it might shift the balance in global financial power dynamics.

While CBDCs hold transformative potential, their adoption is riddled with complexities. Balancing the promises of efficiency and inclusivity with concerns about privacy, centralization, and global financial implications will be crucial as we venture into this new era of digital finance.

The Future Landscape of Central Bank Digital Currencies (CBDCs)

The emergence of CBDCs promises a seismic shift in the global financial landscape. Their potential to revolutionize the monetary system is undeniable, but with this potential come numerous considerations.

Central banks, at the forefront of this evolution, need to address several critical questions:

Endgame of CBDC Adoption: It's essential to evaluate the ultimate goal of CBDCs compared to traditional money. This requires a thorough analysis of the present and future payment landscape and setting realistic targets.
Target Audience for CBDCs: A CBDC's design should cater to its primary users, be they private individuals, businesses, or commercial banks. Leveraging expertise outside conventional central banking circles can offer invaluable insights.
Role of Central Banks: Whether they envision a hands-on approach or a supervisory one, central banks must harness their existing relationships to drive CBDC adoption.
Required Resources & Capabilities: The introduction of CBDCs will demand new decision-making structures, change management strategies, and partnerships.
Beyond Payments: Central banks must anticipate and address regulatory, commercial, and fiscal challenges to achieve their adoption objectives.

Beyond central banks, various stakeholders must adapt to the new CBDC-driven ecosystem:

Financial Infrastructure Providers: They should ensure their systems are compatible with digital currencies.
Retail Banks & Merchants: Investments in infrastructure will be crucial to modernizing payments and incorporating CBDCs.
Risk Officers & CFOs: They should monitor CBDCs' influence on liquidity and capital requirements.
Cryptocurrency Investors: They need to gauge CBDCs' impact on popular cryptocurrencies.
Commercial Banks: Compliance with KYC norms and anti-money laundering measures will be paramount in a CBDC environment.

However, the implications of CBDCs extend beyond operational changes. They threaten to disrupt the fractional reserve system, where banks lend more than their liquid assets. Should all deposits transition to CBDCs, traditional banks might need to evolve into "loanable funds intermediaries," securing long-term funds for long-term loans. This shift could lead to a narrow banking model, primarily governed by central banks, replacing the current system. Such a change has its merits, including better bank run prevention and enhanced monitoring of lending practices.

CBDCs, when optimally designed, will serve as a secure and neutral asset for payment and settlement. They can foster an inclusive financial architecture, promoting competition and innovation, all while preserving democratic control over currency.

In essence, while uncertainties surround CBDCs, they undeniably stand poised to reshape global finance. As they mature, a clearer understanding of their advantages and challenges will emerge, guiding stakeholders in navigating this new financial frontier.

Please note that Plisio also offers you:

Create Crypto Invoices in 2 Clicks and Accept Crypto Donations

12 integrations

6 libraries for the most popular programming languages

19 cryptocurrencies and 12 blockchains