USDC vs USDT: Which Stablecoin Is Better?

USDC (USD Coin) and USDT (Tether) stand as prominent stablecoins. Defined as crypto assets pegged to maintain value consistency, in this context, to the U.S. dollar, they serve a shared purpose. However, distinctions arise: USDC, backed by Centre Consortium, is heralded for its transparent nature. In contrast, USDT, a product of Tether Limited, is favored due to its liquidity and dominant trading presence. This piece delves deeper into their unique attributes, guiding you in selecting the stablecoin that aligns with your objectives.

What are stablecoins?

Stablecoins, a specialized subset of cryptocurrencies, are ingeniously designed to minimize volatility by anchoring their value to external assets, most commonly to fiat currencies like the U.S. dollar. This unique design ensures that stablecoins, such as USDC and USDT, maintain a nearly consistent value, typically hovering around $1.00, providing a semblance of stability in the otherwise turbulent cryptocurrency market.

Historically, the early days of cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin provided limited options for exchanges. Users could only trade these digital assets for other cryptocurrencies or traditional fiat currencies. This posed a challenge for crypto enthusiasts wanting to shift assets without completely stepping out of the digital realm. Enter stablecoins, bridging this gap and allowing users to stay within the crypto ecosystem.

Apart from serving as a respite from market fluctuations, stablecoins bring the advantages of cryptocurrencies to the forefront—swift, borderless transactions—while significantly reducing risks linked to price swings. By emulating some characteristics of fiat currencies in a digital format, they aim to merge the best of both traditional and crypto financial systems. As a result, they've become a favored choice for traders who seek the flexibility of round-the-clock exchanges without the need to revert to traditional banking. As long as their backing remains consistent, stablecoins are poised to offer a reliable, constant-value digital currency, paving the way for more widespread acceptance and use of crypto assets.

Why are there so many USD stablecoins?

In the vast and evolving landscape of cryptocurrencies, stablecoins like USDT, USDC, Binance's BUSD, and Ethereum's Dai (DAI) stand out due to their unique value proposition. Despite each of them maintaining a nearly equivalent value to $1, their applications and interoperability vary based on the blockchain networks they are designed for. For instance, while USDC and USDT dominate in terms of market capitalization, the choice between BUSD and DAI often hinges on specific network preferences and applications users engage with.

Distinguishing them further from traditional fiat currencies, stablecoins are exclusively digital, devoid of any physical counterpart. While fiat represents tangible cash issued and regulated by central banks, stablecoins find their foundation in reserve assets, be it fiat currencies or commodities. This backing aims to ensure value stability, in contrast to fiat, whose value hinges on the confidence and trust in its issuing entity.

Beyond their foundational differences, stablecoins offer several operational advantages. They facilitate instantaneous, cost-effective transactions on blockchain networks, even transcending borders. This swift digital efficiency contrasts with the often sluggish and pricier transfers associated with fiat, particularly in international contexts. Moreover, the decentralized nature of stablecoins shields them from the monetary policies and influences central banks exert on fiat currencies. This decentralized autonomy further cements their position as a compelling digital alternative in the financial ecosystem.

What is USDC?

Introduced in 2018, USD Coin (USDC) emerged from the collaborative efforts of Centre—a consortium born from the partnership between Circle and the renowned cryptocurrency exchange, Coinbase. Notably, Circle, more than just being a founder, has been at the forefront, championing USDC's cause and further enhancing its ecosystem with a range of payment solutions centered around the stablecoin.

USDC's inception was timed during a period marked by skepticism surrounding Tether's (USDT) opaque operations. Seizing this opportunity, a slew of stablecoins, including the likes of Paxos Standard Token (now rebranded as Pax Dollar), Gemini Dollar, and True USD, entered the scene. Among these contenders, USDC has notably outshone its peers in gaining traction and trust.

At its core, the operational mechanics of USDC bear a resemblance to USDT. Striving to maintain a near $1 valuation, USDC boasts a robust backing by reserves under its issuer's purview. The process is straightforward: Users deposit US dollars with a USDC issuer like Circle, which then creates a corresponding volume of USDC tokens. Moreover, Circle facilitates a seamless exchange, allowing users to trade their USDC tokens back for US dollars at a 1:1 ratio.

As the calendar turned to December 2022, the assets underpinning USD Coin comprised a mix of liquid cash and short-term U.S. Treasuries. Since its debut, Circle has consistently showcased its commitment to transparency, releasing monthly attestations verified by Grant Thornton LLP. This move showcased USDC's reserves adequacy, setting it apart from USDT—though it's worth noting that Tether has since taken strides to enhance its transparency.

Initially anchored to the Ethereum blockchain, USDC has expanded its horizons, finding compatibility with multiple blockchain platforms, including Algorand, Solana, Stellar, and more.

What is USDT?

Originating from the visionaries at the Hong Kong-based Tether Limited in 2014, USDT emerged as a groundbreaking solution aimed at melding the realms of fiat and cryptocurrency. This innovative stablecoin presented users with a blockchain-driven US Dollar, encapsulating the technical prowess inherent to assets like Bitcoin and Ethereum. Yet, it deftly sidestepped their notorious volatility, offering high liquidity.

Tether ingeniously amalgamated the strengths of both the fiat and crypto sectors, crafting a decentralized avenue for dispatching crypto-dollars globally. This came with the perks of swift transactions, clear transparency, and economical costs, thereby broadening the crypto horizon to encompass remittances, diversified payments, and beyond.

With its debut, USDT swiftly became a coveted asset, finding itself paired with a myriad of cryptocurrencies across trading platforms. This rapid adoption endowed Tether with a pioneering edge in the burgeoning stablecoin arena. Fast forward to the present, and a staggering 74.7 billion USDT tokens are seamlessly integrated across prominent blockchains like Bitcoin, Ethereum, EOS, Algorand, Tron, and others. Its ubiquity is evident as USDT stands as the preferred trading match within the crypto sphere, facilitating trades and swaps for countless other digital assets.

USDT's versatility extends beyond mere trading. It enables swift, cost-effective transactions, fosters earning potential within decentralized finance protocols, and empowers merchants to embrace crypto payments denominated in fiat. All this, while circumventing the market uncertainties that traditionally volatile cryptocurrencies might bring.

Safety and transparency

Tether's USDT has often been the subject of debate, primarily due to the company's reluctance to frequently unveil detailed insights about the coin's backing. Contrasting this, USDC's overseeing entity, Centre Consortium, has steadily adhered to regulations, consistently unveiling audited reserve reports.

Though Tether eventually disclosed a reserve breakdown in March 2021, it wasn't without resistance. They actively sought to keep their reserve details under wraps, even petitioning the New York Supreme Court to prevent the state's Attorney General from disclosing documents to CoinDesk, who had initiated a Freedom of Information Law (FOIL) request.

In the ensuing period, Tether has endeavored to enhance transparency by detailing their reserves and offering daily updates. Nonetheless, entities like the Commodity Futures Trading Commission continue to urge Tether to conduct a comprehensive audit.

Meanwhile, USDC takes a proactive approach, aligning with current regulations and preparing for potential future legislative changes. Circle, responsible for USDC, conducts monthly reserve audits via the reputable accounting entity, Grant Thornton LLP. Their commitment extends to maintaining reserves in US dollars and short-term treasury bills, with considerations even extending to procuring a national charter for a digital banking venture.

Circle's CEO, Jeremy Allaire, emphasized this stance in a conversation with the Brookings Institute, stating, “USDC's regulated status, overseen by banking authorities in line with regulations governing platforms like PayPal, Apple, or Square, has been pivotal since its inception. Such statutes bolster public trust in these digital payment platforms, which is paramount”.

USDC vs. USDT: Understanding the differences

Both USDC and USDT share foundational similarities, standing as fiat-backed stablecoins anchored to the value of the US dollar. Their utility in daily transactions, combined with their presence across diverse blockchains, offers enhanced accessibility. The seamless, rapid peer-to-peer transfers further underscore their practicality. However, delving deeper reveals distinct differences that can guide users in their choice between the two:

Market Capitalization: This metric sheds light on an asset's overall market worth, reflecting the total number of coins minted and actively circulating. Determined by the interplay of supply and demand, it offers insights into the asset's potential trajectory. As of this analysis, USDC boasts a market cap of $27 billion, whereas USDT towers with a cap of $83.7 billion. This disparity has remained consistent, with USDT often showcasing a more expansive liquid trading volume.
Asset Backing: The stability of these coins stems from their backing by other tangible assets. While USDC's value is underpinned by cash and its equivalents, USDT draws its stability from a diversified pool of cash, short-term treasuries, and liquid debt instruments. These reserve assets bolster the liquidity and reliability of the stablecoins.
Regulatory Landscape: USDC operates within a stringent regulatory framework, not limited to its oversight by Centre. It aligns with US directives, especially in areas like anti-money laundering and customer identification protocols, ensuring its operations are consistently under the watchful eyes of US regulators. Conversely, the regulatory alignment of USDT remains somewhat ambiguous, casting a shadow over its compliance status.

What happens if USD collapses?

Given that both USDC and USDT are anchored to the US dollar, it's reasonable to speculate that a potential decline in the USD could impact their value. Since both stablecoins have cash reserves, a dip in USD might also reflect in their liquidity. However, such a drastic shift in the USD's value remains a distant concern for most.

While there have been instances where these stablecoins slightly deviated from their peg to the US dollar (hovering just below the $1.00 mark), the complete devaluation of a major fiat currency remains a rare and improbable event.

On another note, what if the crypto market eclipses the USD's dominance? Some industry luminaries, including BlackRock's Larry Fink, believe that the global nature of cryptocurrencies might lead to such a scenario. Given the ambiguous regulatory stance on crypto in major economies like the US, South Korea, Australia, Germany, and Japan, this notion gains some weight.

Should cryptocurrencies overshadow traditional fiat, new regulatory structures, akin to MiCA, will become imperative. In such a landscape, stablecoins might see a surge in adoption, even if their intrinsic value remains constant.

Please note that Plisio also offers you:

Create Crypto Invoices in 2 Clicks and Accept Crypto Donations

12 integrations

6 libraries for the most popular programming languages

19 cryptocurrencies and 12 blockchains