What Is a Smart Contract Audit?

A smart contract audit is a comprehensive review process that meticulously examines the code of a contract to uncover security vulnerabilities, coding errors, and inefficiencies, with the aim of identifying corrective measures to enhance the contract's safety and efficiency. This step is crucial for the integrity and functionality of blockchain applications, as the immutable nature of smart contracts means that their code effectively becomes law once deployed. Errors or vulnerabilities in the code cannot be rectified post-deployment without incurring significant costs and delays, necessitating a new version to be developed and deployed.

In the realm of Decentralized Finance (DeFi), smart contract audits are indispensable. They offer a deep dive into a protocol’s codebase to pinpoint bugs and inefficiencies, ensuring that smart contracts are secure and impenetrable. Given the immutable nature of blockchain technology, any flaws can lead to irreversible loss of user funds, a scenario that has already cost the DeFi sector over $5 billion due to hacks. Thus, audits are not just a best practice but a critical component of a blockchain project's security strategy.

Smart contract audits are particularly vital for decentralized applications (dApps), which operate on immutable blockchains. The stakes are high, as any vulnerability in the code could lead to irreversible financial losses for users. Through the auditing process, developers gain insights into potential security flaws, inefficient coding practices, and strategies for optimizing gas usage in Solidity, the programming language for Ethereum smart contracts. The process also involves the use of specialized tools designed to facilitate thorough and effective audits.

By ensuring that smart contracts are devoid of vulnerabilities and coded efficiently, smart contract audits play a pivotal role in safeguarding the DeFi ecosystem against hacks and ensuring the reliability and security of blockchain-based applications.

Why Are Smart Contract Audits Important?

While blockchain technology itself is known for its security, applications built on blockchain, such as smart contracts, are not immune to vulnerabilities. High-profile security breaches, like the $50 million theft from the DAO in 2016 due to exploitable smart contract code, underscore the critical importance of rigorous smart contract audits. These audits are essential in identifying and mitigating security risks, ensuring that smart contracts are both secure and operate as intended.

The cost of creating and deploying a smart contract can vary significantly, ranging from $7,000 to $45,000, and even reaching up to $100,000 for contracts deployed by large organizations. Given these substantial investments, the comprehensive audit methodology, which combines manual line-by-line analysis with automated tools, offers a valuable safeguard. It not only secures the blockchain application before launch but also instills confidence in investors and users about the reliability and safety of their financial assets.

Security concerns in smart contract deployment are paramount today, with inefficiencies, vulnerabilities, and potential misbehavior leading to substantial financial risks. The irreversible nature of smart contracts means that even minor coding errors can have major consequences, as evidenced by the DAO incident, which resulted in a loss of around $60 million in Ether and a hard fork of the Ethereum network. Consequently, smart contract auditing has become a crucial step in the development process for its ability to prevent costly errors, enhance security, and ensure continuous assessment of the code's integrity.

A quality smart contract audit achieves two main goals: ensuring security and building trust. By identifying potential issues and vulnerabilities, audits help protect user funds and establish a baseline level of security that gains the confidence of the crypto community and potential investors. This process is increasingly becoming a standard practice before deploying major updates or launching new projects to avoid "testing in production." Moreover, the scope of security services has expanded beyond audits to include penetration testing, bug bounty programs, and vulnerability assessments, offering comprehensive security solutions for blockchain projects.

For projects seeking reputable auditors, it's important to consider factors such as the auditor's track record, the thoroughness of their review process, and the additional security services they offer. Engaging a skilled auditor not only ensures the technical soundness of smart contracts but also contributes to the overall security and credibility of the blockchain ecosystem.

How Much Does a Smart Contract Audit Cost?

Smart contract auditing is a critical service that comes with a cost reflective of its importance and complexity. On average, auditing providers charge between $5,000 and $15,000, though this price can escalate significantly depending on the intricacy of the smart contract and the specific demands of the project. The necessity for such audits stems from the essential role smart contracts play in executing financial transactions and their reliance on bug-free code to function correctly.

The auditing process is meticulous and detailed, involving a line-by-line review of the contract's code to identify potential vulnerabilities and areas for improvement. This labor-intensive task is the primary reason for the high cost associated with smart contract audits. Auditors not only examine the code for flaws but also assess how the contract aligns with current security trends, providing a comprehensive report that outlines detected issues and recommends enhancements to bolster security.

Given the critical nature of these audits in identifying and rectifying code vulnerabilities—which, if left unaddressed, could lead to significantly higher costs and security risks—the investment in a smart contract audit is seen as essential. The duration of a smart contract audit varies, ranging from a quick two days for smaller projects to up to a month for larger, more complex protocols. After the initial audit, clients are advised on corrective measures, with the timeline for implementing these fixes dependent on the client's resources and priorities. A follow-up remediation check, typically completed in a day, ensures that all recommended adjustments have been effectively applied.

In conclusion, while the upfront cost of smart contract auditing may seem steep, the value it provides in ensuring the security and functionality of blockchain applications makes it an indispensable part of deploying reliable and trustworthy smart contracts.

How to Choose a Smart Contract Auditor

Selecting the right smart contract auditor involves a careful examination of their track record, specifically the range and prominence of the projects they have audited. A critical aspect to consider is whether any of the audited platforms have suffered from security breaches, as this could indicate the effectiveness of the auditor's scrutiny. The caliber of projects an auditor has worked on also speaks volumes; auditors involved with high-profile projects are likely more experienced in identifying vulnerabilities that could attract malicious actors.

The capability to audit contracts on various blockchain platforms, beyond Ethereum, is another crucial criterion. The blockchain ecosystem is diverse, with platforms like Solana, Polygon, Avalanche, Fantom, and BNB offering unique features and, in some cases, employing distinct programming languages, such as Rust for Solana and NEAR. Evaluating an auditor's proficiency across these various environments is essential, especially for projects built on less common or emerging blockchains. Confirming an auditor's experience with the specific blockchain your project uses, through their portfolio, can provide reassurance of their suitability for your audit needs.

The methodology an audit firm employs is also a key consideration. The depth and breadth of an audit can significantly impact its duration and cost, as well as its ability to uncover potential issues. A comprehensive audit not only assesses current vulnerabilities but also considers the future scalability and upgradability of the project, factoring in the quality of the code to prevent long-term complications.

Lastly, the audit report itself is a vital component of the auditor's deliverables. An effective report will detail all discovered issues, their potential impact, and recommended fixes, in a format that is accessible to both technical and non-technical stakeholders. It's important that the report also follows up on whether the audited projects have addressed the identified vulnerabilities. A well-structured, clear, and concise audit report not only demonstrates the auditor's thoroughness but also their ability to communicate complex issues in an understandable manner, which is invaluable for ensuring the security and reliability of smart contracts.

HACKEN

Hacken, established in Ukraine in 2017, has rapidly grown into a leading blockchain security firm. Within just six years, it has scaled to employ over 100 professionals and serve more than 1,000 clients, encompassing cryptocurrency exchanges, tokens, and decentralized applications (dApps). To date, Hacken has conducted audits for 1,200 projects, including high-profile crypto entities such as The Sandbox, Aptos, Binance, Aave, Yearn, and Polygon.

Audit Services Offered:

Comprehensive smart contract audits to uncover vulnerabilities and enhance functionality.
Proof of Reserves audits and validations for cryptocurrency exchanges.
Thorough audits of blockchain protocols to mitigate hacking risks.
Extensive decentralized application (dApp) audits to detect bugs.
Expert penetration testing conducted by seasoned security specialists.
A bug bounty program that leverages the power of the crowd for penetration testing.

Advantages:

A seasoned security team comprising over 100 experts.
An extensive and successful portfolio showcasing a wide array of security services.

Limitations:

Lack of advisory services.

Hacken distinguishes itself with clear, straightforward audit reports accessible via their website, which succinctly document discovered issues and the resolutions implemented by development teams. The clarity and understandability of these audit reports are crucial for the growth of dApps, as they directly cater to end-users' needs. Additionally, Hacken's bug bounty program harnesses the collective expertise of a global talent pool, enhancing the security of dApps through collaborative efforts.

CERTIK

Founded in 2018 by professors from Columbia University and Yale University, CertiK has quickly ascended to become a leading name in web3 security. Known for its thorough smart contract audits and security verifications, CertiK has served high-profile clients such as Polygon, Binance, Yearn Finance, and Aave, cementing its status as one of the blockchain industry's most trusted security firms.

Audit Services Include:

In-depth smart contract audits to pinpoint vulnerabilities and propose remediation strategies.
Bug bounty programs that invite ethical hackers to assess the security of blockchain platforms.
Immediate cyber incident response services.
Comprehensive penetration testing.
Cryptocurrency due diligence and advisory services.
Advanced wallet tracing and visualization tools.

Advantages:

A robust reputation bolstered by successful audits for top-tier projects.
Support from major industry players like Coinbase, Binance, and SoftBank.
The provision of advisory services alongside security audits to offer holistic security solutions.

Disadvantages:

The premium nature of CertiK's services may come with a higher cost.

CertiK's audit methodology is rigorous and detail-oriented, employing a dual-inspection approach where two independent code inspectors evaluate the code separately. These assessments are then reviewed by a senior auditor, ensuring a comprehensive and multifaceted audit process. This tri-level approach to smart contract auditing significantly enhances the security of the code, providing a solid foundation of trust before the deployment of a smart contract.

HALBORN

Since its inception in 2019, Halborn has quickly established itself as a leader in the field of security and smart contract expertise, garnering trust from leading names within the cryptocurrency world. The firm is known for its rapid delivery, with audit turnaround times between two to four weeks, without compromising on the depth of their analyses. Their comprehensive audits include code reviews, static and dynamic analysis, and financial testing. Halborn's impressive client list features prominent projects like Solana, Polygon, Sushi, and Phantom.

Audit Services Provided:

State-of-the-art penetration testing.
Detailed smart contract audits.
Expert security advisory services.

Strengths:

The firm is praised for conducting thorough audits within a notably quick timeframe.
Halborn has a broad range of experience across various protocols and programming languages.
It offers specialized security advisory services to its clients.

Limitations:

Halborn's experience with Cardano/Plutus remains unclear.

In a remarkably short period, Halborn has made significant contributions to the crypto industry, identifying critical vulnerabilities, such as the "demonic vulnerability", which impacted numerous crypto wallets. Beyond their audit services, Halborn also contributes to the broader crypto and security communities by creating educational content. They have authored the SANS SEC 554 Blockchain and Smart Contract Security Course and have co-authored another course, demonstrating their commitment not only to enhancing security but also to advancing knowledge within the field.

Benefits of Engaging a Smart Contract Auditor

Error Detection: The primary advantage for cryptocurrency projects in employing auditors is the identification of errors overlooked by the development team. This is not a reflection of one programmer's skills over another but rather the value of an additional, impartial review of the code. An external audit team brings a fresh perspective, devoid of any emotional or financial ties to the project, enhancing the overall quality and security of the code.

Enhanced Security: Given the financial nature of many crypto protocols, involving tokens or value transfers such as NFTs, ensuring the code operates as intended is crucial for protecting user and treasury assets from risks.

Increased Efficiency: In networks like Ethereum and its Layer 2 solutions, where gas fees are incurred for network usage, overly complex code can result in higher transaction costs for users. Projects that fail to optimize their code for efficiency risk losing users to more cost-effective alternatives.

Reputation Management: Experienced cryptocurrency users typically will not engage with a project without first examining its documentation and audit reports. A lack of an audit report can quickly lead to negative social media exposure through channels like Telegram, Twitter, and Discord. Securing an audit from a reputable firm not only bolsters a project's credibility but also encourages community support and advocacy.

Risks Associated with Smart Contract Audits

Oversights: No audit can account for every potential issue; most protocol breaches are exploits rather than direct hacks, exploiting unexpected loopholes within the code. While smart contract and targeted dApp audits are critical tools for enhancing security, they cannot provide absolute assurance against vulnerabilities.

Potential Delays: The audit process can introduce delays, ranging from several days to months, depending on the audit's complexity and findings. Projects must be prepared for potential setbacks, ensuring sufficient runway to accommodate these delays before launching and generating revenue.

Financial Costs: The investment in a smart contract audit, while mitigating risk, represents a significant financial and time commitment. Costs vary widely, from $5,000 to $10,000 for simpler token audits to upwards of $70,000 for more complex contracts in the DeFi space, coupled with potentially lengthy waiting periods for audit completion.

Engaging a smart contract auditor presents a balanced equation of benefits and risks, where the advantages of enhanced security, error detection, efficiency improvements, and reputational gains must be weighed against the potential for oversights, launch delays, and substantial financial costs.

Please note that Plisio also offers you:

Create Crypto Invoices in 2 Clicks and Accept Crypto Donations

12 integrations

6 libraries for the most popular programming languages

19 cryptocurrencies and 12 blockchains