CoinTracker: Pros, Cons and Features

CoinTracker stands out as a leading cryptocurrency tax software, offering intuitive tools that facilitate accurate crypto accounting and significantly reduce the time required for manual processing.

This review explores the software from an experiential perspective, detailing its features, customer support, and how it compares with other cryptocurrency tax platforms. It emphasizes CoinTracker's robust integration capabilities with various exchanges and wallets, catering to a diverse user base from casual traders to dedicated investors. The review also highlights the software's real-time portfolio tracking and tax loss harvesting functionalities, which are pivotal in distinguishing CoinTracker in the crowded market of crypto tax solutions.

What Is CoinTracker?

CoinTracker is a cryptocurrency accounting application designed to monitor all your transactions, gains, and losses, simplifying the tax filing process with the IRS.

Accounting in the realm of cryptocurrency is notoriously complex. Each instance of spending, selling, or exchanging cryptocurrency constitutes a taxable event that must be meticulously recorded. For those deeply engaged in cryptocurrency trading, the volume of these transactions can accumulate rapidly over the year.

Moreover, even transactions where one cryptocurrency is traded for another are treated by the IRS as a sale that must be accounted for in US dollars, followed by a purchase with a new cost basis also in US dollars. This can make the accounting process quite perplexing.

To address these challenges, crypto tax software like CoinTracker is essential. It automates the calculation of these transactions simultaneously and accurately, eliminating the need for manual record-keeping.

How Does CoinTracker Work?

CoinTracker operates by linking directly to your preferred cryptocurrency exchanges and wallets, gathering all pertinent data to accurately identify each transaction and taxable event.

The software consolidates this transaction history into a single location, classifying each transaction as a gain, a loss, or income. When the data compilation is complete, CoinTracker generates tax-ready documents, including IRS Form 8949 and 1040 Schedule D.

Furthermore, CoinTracker seamlessly integrates with popular tax software such as TurboTax and H&R Block, facilitating the incorporation of your crypto taxes with your overall annual tax filings. For those who prefer a unified approach, CoinTracker offers an option to file all your taxes directly through its platform, enhancing convenience and efficiency. This integration not only simplifies the filing process but also ensures accuracy and compliance with the latest tax regulations, providing peace of mind for crypto investors.

CoinTracker Key Features

Streamlined Account Import: Effortlessly import your transaction data from major cryptocurrency exchanges and wallets, including Coinbase and MetaMask, among hundreds of other sources. This feature ensures a comprehensive capture of all relevant crypto activities.

Flexible Export Options: Conveniently export your crypto transaction records to leading tax software applications such as H&R Block and TurboTax. Alternatively, you can download completed tax forms for independent filing, providing flexibility in how you manage your tax obligations.

NFT Transaction Tracking: Stay on top of your Non-Fungible Token (NFT) activities with dedicated support for tracking purchases and sales. This is essential for accurate tax reporting of these digital assets.

Extensive DeFi Protocol Support: Access transaction data from over 20,000 Decentralized Finance (DeFi) protocols, including popular platforms like Uniswap and Aave. This extensive support ensures that all aspects of your crypto financial activities are thoroughly documented for tax purposes.

Pros and Cons of CoinTracker

CoinTracker is particularly well-suited for users who frequently transact on centralized exchanges such as Coinbase and engage with well-known DeFi protocols. However, like many crypto tax software platforms, CoinTracker may require manual adjustments for transactions involving less common tokens or protocols before users can finalize their tax filings.

Pros

Broad Compatibility: Supports over 500 exchanges and wallets, ensuring comprehensive transaction tracking.
Flexible Export Options: Users can export their crypto transaction data to popular tax software or directly download IRS-compliant forms.
Complimentary Portfolio Tracking: Offers a free portfolio tracker that updates daily, helping users stay informed about their investments.

Cons

Limited Tax-Loss Harvesting: The tax-loss harvesting feature is only available on the Prime plan, which may require an upgrade for access.
Customer Support Issues: There have been some user complaints regarding the effectiveness and responsiveness of the customer support team.

Supported Wallets, Exchanges, and Protocols in CoinTracker

CoinTracker offers extensive support for the cryptocurrency community, compatible with over 500 wallets and exchanges. It's important to note that while many of these connections are direct, some require the use of .csv files for data importation.

The platform also supports a vast array of over 20,000 Decentralized Finance (DeFi) protocols. Below is a brief overview of the types of platforms CoinTracker integrates with:

Exchanges: Notable examples include Coinbase, Binance, Gemini, eToro, and Nexo, which are among the most popular platforms for cryptocurrency transactions.
Blockchains: CoinTracker is compatible with a range of major blockchains such as Bitcoin, Ethereum, Polygon, Arbitrum, Optimism, Avalanche, Solana, Tron, and Cardano, covering a significant spectrum of the crypto ecosystem.
Hot Wallets: The software supports various widely-used hot wallets including Coinbase Wallet, MetaMask, Exodus, Trust Wallet, and Phantom, facilitating seamless tracking and management of assets.
Hardware Wallets: For those who prioritize security, CoinTracker integrates with leading hardware wallets like Ledger and Trezor.
DeFi Protocols: CoinTracker extends its functionality to some of the most influential DeFi protocols such as Uniswap, 1inch, dYdX, Aave, and Compound, ensuring users can manage and report on their DeFi interactions effectively.

CoinTracker Pricing

CoinTracker offers a variety of pricing plans tailored to different levels of cryptocurrency activity, starting with a free plan designed primarily as a demo. This free version imposes no transaction limits but does not allow users to download their tax forms, serving more as an introduction to the platform’s capabilities.

The "Base" plan is priced at $29 annually, offering tracking for up to 100 transactions. For those needing more capacity, the "Base+" plan is available for $99 per year, increasing the transaction limit to 250. Both plans include integration with TurboTax and H&R Block, as well as portfolio tracking features. However, staking reward tracking is capped at $25, which may be restrictive for some users.

For more extensive needs, the "Prime" and "Prime+" tiers are priced at $199 and $299 per year, respectively. These plans significantly expand transaction capacity to 1,000 and 2,500 transactions and provide unlimited staking value tracking. Prime tier subscribers benefit from priority customer support and have access to advanced features such as performance tracking and tax loss harvesting, which are not available in the Base plans.

At the high end, CoinTracker offers the "Ultra" and "Ultra+" plans for users with very high transaction volumes. These are priced at $599 and $1999 per year, accommodating up to 10,000 and 250,000 transactions, respectively. Subscribers to these tiers receive 24-hour customer support and additional functionalities like detailed tax lot breakdowns, the ability to change the cost-basis method annually, and early access to new platform features.

CoinTracker Reports And Export Integrations

CoinTracker provides various options for filing your cryptocurrency taxes, available exclusively to subscribers.

Form 8949: Essential for reporting sales and dispositions of capital assets, including cryptocurrencies, CoinTracker automates the completion of this form by categorizing your transactions into long-term and short-term gains and losses.
Schedule D: Part of IRS Form 1040, Schedule D is crucial for summarizing your capital gains and losses. CoinTracker also prepares this form, allowing you to download it for filing alongside your other tax documents.
CSV Export: For users who opt to file their taxes through platforms requiring CSV format, such as OLT (the IRS's free tax service), CoinTracker facilitates this by providing a detailed spreadsheet of your crypto transactions in the necessary format.
H&R Block and TurboTax Integration: CoinTracker supports exports tailored to the formats required by major tax software like H&R Block and TurboTax, ensuring seamless integration and filing.
Tax-loss Harvesting: Available with the Prime subscription tier, which starts at $199 annually, CoinTracker’s tax-loss harvesting feature is designed to optimize your tax situation. It identifies opportunities to offset taxable gains with losses from your trades, effectively reducing your overall capital gains tax liability.

Ideal Users of CoinTracker

This review of the CoinTracker app reveals its particular strengths, which are especially beneficial for specific user groups:

Traders on Centralized Exchanges: For those who conduct their cryptocurrency trading on centralized exchanges such as Coinbase, CoinTracker offers seamless integration. The app effortlessly syncs with prominent exchanges to import data related to trades and staking income, ensuring comprehensive tracking and reporting.
Users of Mainstream DeFi Platforms: While navigating lesser-known DeFi platforms can be challenging due to support limitations for obscure tokens and platforms, CoinTracker excels with mainstream Layer-2 solutions and even manages unusual meme tokens on major blockchains efficiently.
Individuals with Limited Crypto Transactions: For users with a smaller volume of transactions, CoinTracker's pricing structure is particularly advantageous, making it cost-effective for managing up to 100 transactions.
Crypto Tax Filers: Individuals looking for a streamlined way to handle their crypto-related tax filings will find CoinTracker's automated form generation and export options highly valuable.
Investors Seeking Portfolio Insights: Those interested in detailed insights and updates on their cryptocurrency portfolio will benefit from CoinTracker’s comprehensive tracking and reporting capabilities.
Users Interested in Tax Optimization: With features like tax-loss harvesting available in higher-tier plans, CoinTracker is also ideal for investors looking to optimize their tax obligations related to cryptocurrencies.

Please note that Plisio also offers you:

Create Crypto Invoices in 2 Clicks and Accept Crypto Donations

12 integrations

6 libraries for the most popular programming languages

19 cryptocurrencies and 12 blockchains